Delivering the Diagnosis

You’ve probably read in People that I’m a nice guy – but when the doctor first told me I had Parkinson’s, I wanted to kill him.

Michael J Fox

Did you feel the same way when you got your diagnosis of Parkinson’s Disease? Almost every week, I hear from someone who was recently diagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease. Many of them had a terrible experience getting their diagnosis and probably did want to kill the messenger. When the doctor said those 3 terrible words: ”You have Parkinson’s“, what they really heard was “You have an incurable, chronic, progressive neurologic disease.“ For many, that meant a not too distant future of being hunched over and shuffling, or confined to a wheelchair, shaking from uncontrolled tremors. They didn’t know who to turn to for help. 

Which of these two scenarios describes your experience?

Photo by SHVETS production on Pexels.com
  1. After seeing 2-3 doctors, you finally see one willing to make the diagnosis of Parkinson’s Disease. You feel relief that you have a diagnosis, but the doctor gave you no information about living with the disease. Just a prescription and a return appointment in 3-6 months. You are in shock, scared and don’t know what questions to ask. And 3 months is a long time to wait to get answers. Now what do you do?
  2. You see a Neurologist or Movement Disorders Specialist who takes the time with you after giving you a diagnosis of PD to answer your questions, gives you some printed materials about PD or websites to turn to for more information and support. She tells you to exercise to slow down the progression of the disease. There is a Parkinson’s Nurse available for you to call when you need help or have more questions. Maybe you will even get referred to another person with Parkinson’s to talk to.

15 years ago, when I was diagnosed, the first scenario was all too common. There was almost no information on the internet at the time about living well with PD. My first neurologist told me that I had a Parkinson’s like tremor and put me on medication (Requip, not Sinemet). Not knowing much about PD at the time, I didn’t know what to ask about my future living with this tremor. Would it get worse? Was I going to be disabled? What could I do to feel better? So many questions unanswered. 

Eventually I asked my general practioner to refer me to someone else. The Movement Disorders Specialist I saw changed my life, literally. She spent time with me to answer my questions, gave me information about living with PD and referred me to several websites that were quite helpful. And she said that the type of PD that I had was relatively slow moving and that I could live a normal life for a long time. She gave me hope – which was the most important thing of all.

Delivering the Diagnosis

Last month, a paper was published in Parkinsonism and Related Disorders, titled  Delivering the diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease: Setting the stage with hope and compassion . Who was the lead researcher? My wonderful MDS who I have been seeing for almost 15 years, Indu Subramanian, MD. She and co-authors Kuhan Pushparatnam, Bradley McDaniels, Soania Mathur, Bart Post and Anette Schrag address the many challenges that come with giving a diagnosis of PD.

“The diagnosing clinician is the person who will deliver the life changing information of a disease that is chronic, progressive, and associated with numerous symptoms and long-term disability, which commonly elicits fear and uncertainty in the person receiving the news. Because of the significant emotional impact, many patients vividly remember their diagnosis and how it was delivered many years later. Being mindful of the shock of this diagnosis and how the information is delivered while considering what patients find difficult or comforting in the messaging is, therefore, the key to providing the best possible experience for patients at this crucial time.”

Unfortunately, 15 years later, things still haven’t changed much. Too many doctors, even MDS, don’t know how to give the diagnosis in a compassionate way, to give the patient the emotional support that they need at this time. I hope that this paper will be a wake up call to all doctors who treat Parkinson’s patients. 

For more information for the newly diagnosed, go to my post Advice for the Almost Diagnosed.

Parkinson’s Hack of the Week

Bathtub and Shower Non-slip stickers

A fall in the shower is not a good thing. There are a lot of different non-slip stickers that will make your shower safer. Choose from whimisical patterns to transparent. From $5.99- $13.99 on Amazon.


Have a great week!

4 responses to “Delivering the Diagnosis”

  1. Robert Cochrane Avatar
    Robert Cochrane

    Great blog! I love that you continue to shine light on this part of living with PD – by dealing with the root (diagnosis, and the feelings, actions and inactions that happen afterward) we can get clarity on how to live our best going forward.

    Robert Cochrane, PhD

      1. lizzie555 Avatar

        My diagnosis came from a researcher who was kind and hopeful. However, he didn’t treat patients. The next doctor gave me pills and said to come back when I couldn’t get in the car or button my shirt. Needless to say, I looked further and found two wonderful doctors.

        I heard the following from Dr. Mark Stacy, a neurologist, in a class he was teaching.
        He said:

        So one of my pet peeves is how badly neurologists make the diagnosis of Parkinson’s Disease and patients don’t recover from that. You have a chance to help them recover. And so, when I make a diagnosis of Parkinson’s Disease, I stop, and I tell a patient and family, “Okay I’m going to say something to you that’s really bad. And I want you to take a deep breath because it’s going to get better from now on because what you think of what I’m about to tell you is much different than what I think of it.” And so then I tell them, “I believe you have Parkinson’s Disease and this is why.”  And then I say, “Now stop, everything’s going to get better, and please listen to how you’re going to be responsible for managing a 30 year illness.” 

        There are many neurologists who I’ve heard, say, “You need to get  your things in order,” and it’s just an absolutely horrible irrecoverable thing to say to any other human being. But your responsibility is to the health of the patient, and so when you have that opportunity to begin providing optimism and providing hope, that’s when you need to start.

      2. Sharon Krischer Avatar

        Lizzie, very wise advice from Dr. Stacy. I wish more would follow his example.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

I’m Sharon

Welcome to Twitchy Woman.

I started Twitchy Woman as a way to exchange ideas and solutions with other whose lives have been affected. It has been recognized by Everyday Health, Healthline, Stanford University and more as one of the top Parkinson’s blogs to follow. Each month I host a free Zoom webinar exclusively for other “Twitchy Women” with Parkinson’s Disease.

Feel free to explore the site – there are goodies on every page to help you live your best life with Parkinson’s Disease.

Let’s connect

A Son’s Journey

A new book by super Parkinson’s Advocate George Ackerman

Just out “A Son’s Journey from Parkinson’s DIsease Caregiver to Advocate. I am looking forward to reading this new book today.

Recent Posts

Sunday Mornings with Twitchy Woman

Sunday May 19, 2024

Time for Ping Pong!

Maureen and Trent will talk about Ping Pong for Good – a program for people with PD.

If you live in Los Angeles and want to participate in the live Ping Pong demo, please contact Sharon for details.

Click here to register.

This program is open to everyone.

Want to practice Ping Pong at home but don’t have room for a Ping Pong table?Click on the image to learn more.

Clinical Trials Corner

LIGHTPD

The University of Rochester and Dr. Ray Dorsey have an interesting new clinical trial in which you participate from the comfort of your own home, doesn’t involve changes to your current meds, and you can earn $500.00!  All interactions with the medical  team will be via Zoom and phone. 

Read more here